Harvard Professor Reveals the Science Behind Heartbreak (S4 -E9 )
Host: Kathryn Lancioni
Guest: Christy Denckla
Episode Overview:
When life delivers an unexpected blow, how do we process lossโand how do we begin to move forward? In this episode, Kathryn Lancioni invites Christy Denckla, assistant professor at the Harvard School of Public Health, to share her expertise in the science and lived experience of grief and bereavement. Their conversation ranges from the roots of Christyโs research to Kathrynโs gut-wrenching stories of loss, uncovering how personal and societal responses shape our journey through grief. Together, they explore why loss impacts both body and mind, how stigma and silence can deepen the pain, and the subtle ways that finding supportโinternally and externallyโcan light the way toward healing.
5 Key Lessons from This Episode:
1. Grief Is Universal and Uniquely Personal
Kathryn and Christy demonstrate that while all humans encounter grief, each personโs pathway through it is their own. Thereโs no single timeline or methodโways of coping and the intensity of emotions are shaped by individual relationships and lived experiences. Recognizing this helps everyone honor their own process rather than compare it to societal norms.
2. Avoidance Isnโt Healing
Christy points out that avoidance tends to prolong or intensify the pain of trauma and grief. Suppressing emotions might feel easier in the moment, but ultimately it can keep us stuck. Kathryn reflects on the difficulties of facing grief directly versus trying to move past it too quickly, noting the value of acknowledging what hurts as the first step toward healing.
3. Our Relationships Literally Shape Our Health
According to Christyโs research, the loss of meaningful relationships can trigger surprising physical reactionsโfrom increased risk of heart disease to long-lasting endocrine changes. Kathrynโs personal stories reveal just how central these bonds are, not just for joy, but for identity and biological well-being.
4. Connection Needs Nuance
Not all support is the sameโand not everyone needs the same type. As Christy explains, community can be healing, but sometimes solitude is essential, especially following a loss. The key is to tune in to your own needs and to seek out spaces (from therapy to community groups or religious organizations) that truly resonate, rather than simply following prescribed norms.
5. Growth May Mean Letting Go
Kathryn shares that her own journey through adversity involved letting go of relationships that no longer served her. Christy affirms that sometimes, prioritizing your well-being means thinning the herd and setting boundaries, even when itโs hard. Self-compassion and surrounding yourself with genuine support are crucial parts of recovery.
This episode is a powerful reminder that gut punchesโthose moments when life turns upside downโdonโt have to define your future. Kathryn and Christy show that healing is possible, and that with time, support, and self-compassion, we can rebuild meaning and connection after loss. Each story, each memory, and each act of reaching out adds up to resilience. There truly is always a way forward, even when the path feels uncertain.
Connect with Christy Denckla:
Dr. Christy Denckla brings a wealth of expertise as an Assistant Professor at Harvard's School of Public Health and a clinical psychologist specializing in trauma, grief, and bereavement. Listeners would benefit from connecting with her to gain deeper, research-driven insights into coping with grief and understanding the nuanced impacts of trauma and social connections on mental and physical health. Her compassionate, informed perspective offers both practical resources and validation for anyone navigating loss or supporting others through it.
- ๐๐ถ๐ป๐ธ๐ฒ๐ฑ๐๐ป: https://www.linkedin.com/in/christy-denckla-phd-146bb11b7/
- ๐ช๐ฒ๐ฏ๐๐ถ๐๐ฒ: https://hsph.harvard.edu/profile/christy-denckla/
Produced by the Digital Transformation Broadcast Network.
[00:00:00] Welcome to Gut Punch, the podcast that explores life-changing moments. Hosted by Kathryn Lancioni, a seasoned educator with personal insights into resilience. Kathryn shares how life can change in an instant, shaping our path forward. Each episode features inspiring guests who face their own gut punch moments. Guests share their journeys through loss, upheaval, and triumph. What to expect, honest conversations, lessons in resilience, inspiration for growth.
[00:00:30] Join Kathryn as she highlights courage and perseverance in every story. Gut Punch is a reminder that there is always a path forward. Be part of the conversation. Register now to join Kathryn for today's journey. Hello, everyone. Welcome to another episode of the Gut Punch podcast. My name is Kathryn Lancioni, and I'm your host for today's episode. Today, I'm delighted, ecstatic,
[00:00:55] and elated to have Brigitte St-Jean. She's an assistant professor at Harvard School of Public Health. She is joining me here today from Cambridge, and I am just thrilled to have her. And I am not going to steal Christy's thunder. So, Christy, welcome to the show. Thank you. Great to be here. I know. I'm so delighted to have you here. And I just would love it if you could introduce yourself and share a little bit about your backstory, and then we'll talk about your work.
[00:01:21] Sure. Great. So, yeah, so excited to be here and really looking forward to our conversation. I am an assistant professor at the School of Public Health at Harvard University. And my background, my training is in clinical psychology. So, I'm trained as a clinical psychologist. And I migrated from clinical psychology with a focus in trauma and bereavement into public health. And from the platform of thinking about mental health, psychiatry, from the public health perspective,
[00:01:51] I have become more interested. My work is now currently focused on social factors, on population wellness, and population mental health with a real interest, again, a core interest in trauma and specifically grief and bereavement. Yeah. And I think trauma and grief and bereavement is something that is so underappreciated because however one experiences trauma, whether it's a health condition, whether it's the death of someone, whether it's firing from work, whether it's getting
[00:02:20] divorced or anything in between, it has a huge impact on us. And I think grief is one subset of that. And when we spoke to Kerstin, we were talking about the effect of trauma on the brain, which was something that I was keenly interested in, given what I've gone through. But if you could talk up, I would love it if you could share with us a little bit about your early research and then the focus that you have today, that would be great. Sure. Yeah. So I'm glad you brought up Kerstin. Kerstin has been a mentor of mine for many years now
[00:02:49] and has really encouraged me to take a scientific focus into grief and bereavement specifically, which is a largely underappreciated public health factor. I think there's a broader appreciation for the physical and even mental effects of trauma, but less of an appreciation for the physical and mental effects of grief and loss. There is less scientific focus in this area, although there
[00:03:15] have been really important luminaries in the field. But there's several interesting reasons why, in my opinion, grief and trauma hasn't been such a scientific focus. So that's really been been the work that I've developed and focus on very, very closely now. So it started from clinical training, really. I don't know how far back should I go? I guess the first story is like,
[00:03:43] what was the catalyst? Did you experience immense grief in your life that led you into this? How did you decide to focus on this? Let's start there. Yeah, it's interesting. Actually, I actually didn't want to focus on this for my scientific or professional career because I had experienced these things as a child in my early childhood. And it was really nothing. I didn't study psychology in undergrad. I did not want to think about it. I didn't want to be in. I really wanted to put it
[00:04:10] behind me. But I always had a passion for service and always had a passion for giving back, making the world a better place. And I was always interested in learning. I love learning. Schools have always been the safe place for me. So I would say there were two catalysts that directed me to a career in clinical psychology after training in really environmental sciences. So
[00:04:35] as an undergrad, I was at McGill University and was doing work in the Canadian Arctic. And I was really interested in how communities interacted with their environment. I was very interested in how national and public governmental regulations affected how people interacted with their environments. So I spent two summers in the Canadian Arctic. And during these times, I got to know some really interesting people. And the communities are small. And I'm also was born in the Canadian North myself.
[00:05:05] So it was a bit of a reconnection to a way of life that I experienced as a child. But at any rate, there was I just what profoundly impacted me at the time were the extent of severe trauma that communities were coping with. Suicide was so common and rampant, physical abuse, physical violence, interpersonal violence. And I had, and this maybe was a bit of a gut punch at the even then,
[00:05:32] but had a profound reckoning with the fact, in my opinion, that absent an understanding of how these experiences shape our lives, we're really unable to engage in pro-social kind of activities and take care of ourselves and our environment. So rather than focusing on the environment and how we interacted with, I became much more interested in focusing internally on the person. Yeah. Yeah. So that
[00:05:58] inspired. So I went back. I went, that's when I started school and training in clinical, clinical psychology. With a focus in job. And I've heard, I know in the United States from Montana, for example, the whole Montana meth thing, right? That I'm sure you're keenly aware of where when people are socially isolated or isolated, it causes immense amounts of loneliness. The WHO, as you and I were talking about before in 2025, just, I guess, said that loneliness is like a global, global epidemic. And it's really,
[00:06:28] really a problem. And if you, and I think that when one experiences grief, and I want to go back to something that you said earlier, the natural, I think my own opinion, the natural thing is mentally we're like, we just want to get through this, right? You just want to get through this. And then you want to put it up on the shelf and forget it ever happened or try to forget it ever happened. What I've learned through my own work, both research wise and communication,
[00:06:55] and also from my own personal experience is that is actually the worst thing that you can do. Because as humans, our natural thing, I think is to want to bury stuff. But the problem is when you don't deal, at least from my own experience, when you don't deal with it, when you don't acknowledge and it just makes it worse. Have you found that in your research and in your work with people?
[00:07:19] Yeah. Well, avoidance as is in 101 trauma training, avoidance is one of the most powerful maintaining mechanisms for the symptoms of trauma reactions. So yeah, avoidance. Now the extent to which avoidance extends to grief is very interesting because a couple of things are going on, I think, to make it a bit different in the case of grief that we know from some of the neuroscience and
[00:07:43] cognitive research. So I'll start with what it means to love someone. So what does it mean? Why do we care in the first place that someone died? I was actually just preparing for a talk and remember Darwin actually was very interested in grief and he was very interested in grief because he asked, why do we persist in the sorrow and difficulty of after a loss when there's no survival benefit, there's no evolutionary advantage, right, to grief really? So why do we grieve? If there's no
[00:08:10] evolutionary advantage, we would imagine it would be more fit to let that go and focus on survival needs, right? So it's a really interesting question. Why do we grieve in the first place? What is the benefit to it from an evolutionary perspective? So what we know from the research, this comes from clinical psychology, from neuroscience, is I tend to think of it as a cognitive architecture of how we perceive the world around us and how we bond and how we find safety and how we create a sense of
[00:08:40] accurate predictions of the future. So this is what comes from attachment research to a large extent, but that from our earliest relationships, we form very profound bonds with the people in our lives. It doesn't necessarily have to be a maternal parent. Oftentimes it is, but children and infants from the very beginning, we were just profoundly social creatures, right? Yes. So the way that that architecture creates a sense of how we perceive the world, how we see the
[00:09:10] world, how we think about the world, mood regulation, when that architecture is disturbed, we can say by a death or by a profound loss, it throws the whole system into a bit of chaos, right? Or into a bit of uncharted territory. So when we're focused, the task of grieving or the work after grief is really a profound reorganization of our worldview. And people take different perspectives on this. We can think about it from a narrative perspective. We can think about it psychoanalytic.
[00:09:39] We think about cognitively, even neuroscientifically. So then the question becomes, so how do we reorganize or find a way to move forward in the world without our loved one in it? Yes. And we learn about there's several neuroanatomical structures involved in this process and even epigenetic changes that occur when bonds are broken and also when bonds form. Yeah. So, all right. So I remember, so I was, you always think about when you were growing up and
[00:10:09] the relationships you formed. And I know for me, the first significant death I remember is when my grandmother died, right? So it was, I was, she was Catherine, I'm Catherine. It was my dad's mom. And I was in eighth grade. And my grandfather had passed away. Her husband had passed away, I don't know, 18 months, two years sooner. They were obviously the greatest generation, that whole group. And truly love and true this concept of heartbreak, which I want to talk to
[00:10:37] you about in a second. So she was heartbroken, which is not some Gen Z term that we throw around. It's an actual thing, which I want to talk about in a second. And I, and so, but she seemed fine. And then she was dead. She had a heart attack and she died. Yeah. I remember, I remember I was in my, in my house that I grew up in, in the family room. And my dad called me and he's like, grandma's gone.
[00:11:01] And I just remember it was like, my heart was pulled out of my body. And I was definitely, I, and, and when I was fortunate, I had four grandparents. The first one died when I was six, the last one died when I was in high school. But for some reason, it was her death that just ripped the core out of my soul. And I, cause I just adored everything about her. I look like her,
[00:11:28] I was named after her. I look like her. My fondest memories as a child were Sundays at her house, making gnocchi or some other form of pasta. And so her loss was, I think my first encounter with grief and, and it sounds really my first encounter with trauma. And I remember, I just felt so empty, you know? And it was, and, and there was no other grandmother alive, right? So she was the last one.
[00:11:56] And so there was no one that I could turn to as a, as another, like, I'm not going to call it replacement relationship, but someone else to fill that void. There was just a void. And it was hard. Wolf Blitzer on CNN always, when they talk about death, may their memory be a blessing. And I learned to accept that, but it was very, very hard. Uh, and I remember feeling very, just lost in terms of,
[00:12:26] how to navigate the emotions associated with that death. So why is it in your research that there, that I think, and I think there's a question here. I think everybody has a death or deaths that just are gut wrenching, right? And the other one, the other one for me has been, it was happened about three years ago. There was someone that I met, an older friend of mine in
[00:12:52] New York that I met when it was my early twenties. And he, I was like the daughter he never had. And he was like my uncle in New York, Ira. And everything I know and love about New York City, I learned from him. I met him when I first moved to New York, when I was working, I met him at the gym of all things. And we were on the stationary bikes and he was next to me and whatever. And, and I knew his wife, I knew his kids, whatever, but he, everything I knew and know about New York City, I learned through him. And that was, and, and I, I do feel guilt associated
[00:13:22] with that friendship because when he passed away and my kids were still in high school and I was still called in the thick of parenting and I didn't call him as much as I wanted to. I didn't share stories that I should have shared with him. And so at the call from his wife that he was in the hospital, literally dying, I just, I just broke down. I was devastated. And it was different devastation than it was with my grandmother when I was little.
[00:13:51] And I don't know whether it was because I was older, whether it was because when I met him in my life, but I, I was literally, I have never cried the way that I cried that day. And I, so I, I, even as I'm telling you this story, I'm getting choked up about it. So I had to go and see him. I had to. And so I did. And I got to say goodbye. And he wasn't really awake, awake, but not really.
[00:14:17] But for me, I, there was an aunt in my life that passed away that I didn't get to say goodbye to, and an uncle too. And I remember that was something that was really important to me with both of those. And I, I regret not being able to, to say goodbye to those people in person, but it was, they were not here logistically. It was really hard. So I remember when, when I was, I've told me that he was dying, I was like, Joyce, I have to come and see him. And so I literally dropped everything I was doing at that moment in time, hopped in the car,
[00:14:44] drove into the city, into New York and went to the hospital. And it was hard because I wasn't actually his daughter, but they pretended that I was his niece. And so I got in, went into, into hospital and was able to see him and to say goodbye. And it was so meaningful to me. And again, that death was like 30 years later than my grandmother. And I still wish that I could pick up the phone and call him. And I can't. And I think for me,
[00:15:12] with that death, with I was passing that, that has been the hardest thing for me because he was so important to me in a way that I did not appreciate until he was gone. And there isn't, every time I go into New York, there isn't a corner that I walk by or a restaurant that I walk by that I'm like, oh my God, we would have lunch there. And it's so hard. And I'm so thankful for that friendship because I learned so much from it and of it. And,
[00:15:40] and they say, and I'm sure you've gotten this with people, that sometimes when people pass, they still send you signals. So I was cleaning out a drawer in my kitchen. This was like right after I recovered from my whole thing. I was home. I couldn't do much. I was like, I might as well clean. So I was like, okay, I'm going to tackle the junk drawer that we all have in our kitchens or somewhere in the house. And I was sorting through stuff and I found this envelope. It was a letter that he had sent me. And, and, and in the letter, there were pictures.
[00:16:09] And I, I just lost it when I found the, when I found the letter and I found the pictures because to me, it was like, he was still here. And, and then a couple of weeks later, I was upstairs cleaning because again, I was home and had nothing to do. And I found the last, he, he was a big one for writing notes, like handwritten notes. And I found a note that he'd written me. It was the last one I ever got from him. And so I just, I felt, I was so sad, but I was
[00:16:37] so happy to find those memories. And as I sit here and cry over this, it, it, it hasn't made it, it's still hard to talk about him, obviously. And he wasn't even a blood relative, but it, but was, what's just so interesting is how people, the loss of someone unexpectedly triggers something inside of you and this feeling of emptiness and feeling of loneliness. Yeah. And I have learned to be happy about the, be appreciative of, I guess is the right word,
[00:17:05] of the fact that he was in my life and the fact that everything I know about New York and so much of what I learned about myself was because of him. But it took me a while to get there. Yeah. So I, I don't know. And I don't think my experience is that different from other people. Why, why is it so profound? Why, why, why? What does your work? Yes. I'll ring you. Tell me all the secrets. No, my goodness. No, thank you. First of all, thank you for sharing the profound experience because
[00:17:34] I, for one thing, your story will touch so many people listening to this podcast because, well, it's unique and very much your own. It is, it is something we don't talk enough about and we don't share enough about. And people feel, I often, this is, this is a personal thought, but we go through life feeling like these are the things we shouldn't talk about. And so, and so there's not a lot of conversation and around these experiences. I think historically,
[00:18:02] we used to, there was much more memorializing of, of, of dead ones. There was much, much, much more porous culturally. And there was a porousness between life and death. Yes. That we've, we've, we've, we've lost a bit. Yes. Yes. I, I think that people, you have someone in your life, they go on to the next stage of life and then it's almost like you're supposed to not talk about them anymore. And then the other, I think I wanted to say this before you go on. This was an epiphany that I had when I ever passed
[00:18:30] away was we in society, someone will say, oh, my, my relative died. They were 85. They were 89. They were 96, whatever. And the reaction is, oh, they lived a good life. Right. And yeah, they did, but it doesn't make it any easier to the person that's still living. And I think that, that there's this perception that, oh, well, you had 80, you had however many years with them. I'm sorry, but, well, there shouldn't be a, but it should just be, I'm sorry. Because it doesn't matter
[00:18:57] if you lose someone, obviously when, when some, when someone dies, it's very young, it's beyond tragic, but to the person on the, who's still alive, death is still hard and grief still hard and loss is still there. And I have, from, from my experience with Ira, I have learned that it doesn't matter if your grandmother was 105. It's still hard that they passed away.
[00:19:23] And I, that's something to get into this, insert into this conversation. Cause I feel like so many times we're like, oh, their relative was 96. Yeah, they were 96. It still hurts them. Cause they don't have that person there anymore. So I just wanted to add that in. Cause I think that's an important thing with this conversation. It is important. I think it's not something we don't do very well in the research we struggle with just in our methods, but each grief is different. Losses are different. We're all different. There's enormous heterogeneity and individual
[00:19:49] variability in these experiences that we, we lose out when we start to look at populations and averages. And, and this is an important, they're important tools scientifically. And we learn a lot from this. For example, one of the things we learn is that there can be upwards of a 90% increase in excess mortality after the death of a spouse, especially older. And that's exactly what you described with your grandmother. Especially in it's most acute in the first three months after the loss. That's interesting.
[00:20:17] It's interesting. And then, and then the risk remits or can go down to baseline in the year after. So I, I, I, speaking of my grandmother in that generation, I just want to talk to you about this concept of heartbreak. So from a, from a clinical or scientific standpoint, what is it? And, and, and how, what is it? Let's start there. Yeah. So there, there's a, there's a syndrome, Takishima, I'm going to pronounce this incorrectly,
[00:20:41] Tashimoko syndrome. It's a syndrome observed clinically that is defined by an acute cardiac event after the death of a loved one. So this is a defined clinical condition, but outside of that, as a, as a sort of a clinical characterization, there is excess risk for cardiovascular disease among, especially among older adults after the death of a spouse or it, this actually occurs across a lifespan. So there's excess cardiovascular risks, like Kirsten's work has pointed this out in PTSD.
[00:21:11] The same is also occurring after the death of a loved one, especially for things like parents losing children, perinatal losses. Among these types of very profound losses, there can be excess risk across a lifespan for morbidity and mortality. We see with children, super interesting in just reviewing these studies as well, for children who lose parents have elevated endocrine dysregulation throughout their life. The cortisol levels remain depressed throughout the lifespan. It's very,
[00:21:38] very, very interesting, the profound effects on our physiology of these, of these losses, which is one of the reasons there's thinking in the field that grief or, or any prolonged grieving course is more of a stress syndrome than it is a, it's, it's characterized best by as a stress syndrome. Yeah, I think so. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So why cardiovascular risk, right? As, as a stress
[00:22:05] syndrome, we can imagine this is, but of course it's not the only health risk that can occur across after, after there's elevated risk for stroke, cancer, several other conditions that, that are known to be an elevated occurrence among bereaved people relative to non-bereaved people in very rigorous epidemiological studies, control for things like reverse causality, for all the things
[00:22:31] that we worry about confounding that might threaten the association, the, the, the direction of the effect. It's, it's just so interesting because I think the term heartbroken is thrown out. Oh, she's heartbroken. It's thrown out, but it's actually a thing. And I, I, I, I find it, I find it fascinating. And I know with my grandparents, I vividly remember they, they were like two peas in a pod. They, and I actually see my parents too. Like they, like when my, my dad and
[00:22:59] my parents are 84 and 83, God bless them. And they're adorable. And I was down there for Father's Day and just seeing their, how they coexist. I'm like, oh my God, you guys, you do you. But there is such love and there is such understanding and respect, but more importantly, there is such, such codependency of that generation on each other. And I remember my dad was in the hospital for something last year for a couple of months actually. And my mom did not know what to do with herself because she was so
[00:23:26] used to my father being around. Yeah. Yeah. Well, the, the, the streams of research, even outside of bereavement that are really illustrating the profound health effects, protective health effects of social relationships. This is, this is like a bulk of research that's been going on for decades that illustrates so unequivocally the, how profoundly important social relationships are for our health and, and not, not just our mental health, of course, but our physical health.
[00:23:51] Well, the whole cost of wellness. Yeah. And I think, and I know, I mean, we could talk about COVID for a second. COVID was just so destructive to all of that. I have students in my classes who have said to me they were super gregarious before COVID. And then they spent two years at home or two years on a zoom screen and now they're afraid of their shadow, literally. Yeah. Talk about a huge blow to mental health and social health. That was COVID for everybody. Yeah. And this is bringing up an
[00:24:21] important point that I, that I always like to remember is that there, the social, the effects of social interactions are nuanced. Yes. It isn't that it's a hundred percent the same. Everyone should be doing the same types of social activities. So important to remember loneliness, the difference between perceived and actual desired social encounters. So someone who does not want a social encounter, who is not with someone is not lonely. Right. Right. Right. Right. The other
[00:24:49] important thing too, is in episodes of intense distress. So for example, in the immediate aftermath of grieving, there are some, there's a process involved in withdrawal. So sadness, the grief of the, the, the, the, the motion of sadness invokes a withdrawal. And that withdrawal can be an important piece of introspecting, of reconciling some of the challenges that people are faced with reconciling, coming to terms with the world without their loved one in it. There is some work from
[00:25:18] ecological momentary analysis showing that when people are experiencing elevated distress and they're around people, their distress can feel more acute. Oh, that's interesting. So it, so in some cases, social interactions can certainly elevate or exacerbate distress. And this is well known to in, for in gender and sex and gender. So for women where there's quite, so the effects of social support are very different for men and women. Yeah. There's some studies,
[00:25:46] some research we've done shows pragmatic support for men can actually worsen mental health. Interesting. Whereas producing or perceived social support, women give, give a lot more social support. So actually social relationships can burden or worsen women's health when those social relationships are associated with, with service or caretaking. Huh. So, so social interaction is very nuanced and very complicated. And I do worry some kinds of
[00:26:15] conversation we can be moving towards a one size fits all that we should all be interacting where we should we're all, but, but the, the piece is, is that there's, there's, there's a deep nuance to, to the effects of social interactions on our health. Sometimes they can actually not help. As you described, I think earlier when you were talking about some of the ways that people can react to a loss in a way that actually isn't helpful for, for the person grieving or can bring assumptions
[00:26:44] to the conversation that aren't there. Well, yes. And so going back to what you were saying about social interactions and people, I, I went through this crazy health journey as people that listen to the show now. And for me, it's like life 2.0, right? So what do you, and I, I've definitely have, have evolved. I'm not going to say change. I've evolved in many ways. I'm still fundamentally the same person, but my perspective on things has changed. And one of them is, or something that's become
[00:27:09] incredibly poignant, it came to be, the point to me through my journey was life is short. The little things matter more than the big. And I feel like we're a society that goes from big to big to big, and it's the little things. Then an example of that for me was at one point I, I couldn't walk, um, because I'd been in bed for so long. And so I remember there were two things I really wanted to do, take my dog for a walk and be able to stand in front of the mirror and wash my face. And those were two things that I
[00:27:37] had taken for granted. And sometimes I didn't want to take my damn dog for a walk, but I had to. And, and so the first time I was able to stand in front of the mirror in my house and wash my face, I cried because it is something that I do every day and something that I took for granted. And then suddenly I couldn't do it. And so that was, that's a little, and then the other thing, but probably the most important was that you need to support, you need to surround yourself with people that love you, want to be with you and support you. And toxic relationships need to go away.
[00:28:03] And there were, there are three, one and one I just ended. There, there were three people in my life that were not supportive, that were toxic and, um, that were causing me an incredible amount of stress. And I made the very hard decision, very, very hard to end those relationships. And one in particular was with a girlfriend that I had known for, I don't know, 30 years, we went to college together.
[00:28:30] And it was just, she didn't show up. She never saw me in the hospital. She never came and saw me at all, whatever. And I literally, as most people know, almost died. And so when, when people that you consider close friends don't show up in your moment, your, your biggest moment of me, what does that say to you? And I thought about that friendship and I was like, you know what? I've, it's been on me, right? She said that give her, take her Ted talk. I was the giver, she was the taker. And so I, I, after something that she said to me post my recovery, she crossed
[00:28:58] a chasm on something that we could never go back on. And I was like, I called her and left her voicemail and said, look, we're done. And I explained why. And it was very, very hard because I knew that I knew that I knew what I was doing and I knew there was no going back, but I will say I, I, I am very glad I made that decision because I did not appreciate the stress that that, that friendship with this, with that person was causing in my life. And I felt very liberated
[00:29:25] afterwards. And I have another girlfriend, a dear, dear friend of mine. She was like, you need to thin the herd sometimes. And it's hard to end those relationships. I have, I've always said one of my biggest weaknesses is I'm, I'm, I'm not good at, I don't quit, right? I, it's not what I do, but I've learned that we get to a point in our life where sometimes we have to make a decision to walk away from something. And that was what I did with that friendship. But, but I'm curious about
[00:29:51] something. So how much of our response, whether in social health, social connections, our design, the whole introvert, extrovert, omnivore thing that's, that's coming out now, how much of that is tied to our upbringing and, and, and the people that influence us as we're young kids? I'm curious about that. Yeah. It's, it's, it's, it's, it's oddly something we don't talk about much as a, as a scientific community, especially as, as public health epidemiology, we think about early social
[00:30:20] conditions. We think about structural factors, we think, and we know these profoundly shape our, our life course. And, and of course, but a clinical psychologist or an analyst would think, have a lot to say about how our early relationships affect our, our life course. And we can, I think we, we, we can say what, what would be the, the, the term something isn't, isn't destiny. I forget the
[00:30:46] term is the same. Yeah. It's not, it's not like, it's not like gonna, it's not going to determine your destiny, but it might make an impact on how you turn. Right. Exactly. But I think the, the lens that I think a lot about this with just from my research side is, is really going back to an attachment perspective in the sense that as we are growing and as we're learning, we're developing some mental models of the world. We're forming memories, we're forming associations, we're learning what's
[00:31:12] reinforcing. We're learning what feels good. We're learning how to, what's safe in the world. We're learning who is safe in the world and how to be around those people more. And, and so those early experiences generate our, our very profoundly the way that we move through the world. Yep. It's not, it's not, it's not destiny. It's not deterministic, but of course those early experiences tell us to some extent what to expect.
[00:31:38] Yeah. Yeah. And, and, and, and going back to what we started talking about before. So you experience a loss, you experience a trauma, it causes grief from a cognitive standpoint, from your research standpoint, how are we impacted? What's the, what's the, the life cycle of grief processing if there is such a thing? I'm curious. Yeah. Thanks for asking that question. So the, there is still to this day, the stage model
[00:32:05] is a very prevalent cultural knowledge around how people cope with loss and grief. There's some expectation that we'll might go through some sort of stages. Of course, Elizabeth Kubler-Ross wasn't the only one to propose a stage model. Many people have suggested that there are expected processes that people might go through. Their research hasn't necessarily confirmed that. And so there is some more, there's a growing conversation around the stage models. Doesn't
[00:32:30] really apply. And it can provide people with an unhelpful sense of what, of prescription and, and, and, and a null personal experience. So personal experiences, of course, is at the profound center of grief. Right. Everybody experiences grief differently. People go through different things. What we can generally say is that in the aftermath of loss, distress is the strongest. That initial reaction is heightened
[00:32:56] distress, heightened stress, heightened, it's extreme. And that occurs not quite as long as we might think. Their research, their difference, their conflicting findings in the literature, but there's some sense that the acute experience peaks in the two, even as early as only as two weeks after and starts to decline. Okay. But by two to three months, we start to see in general longitudinal studies. So a general reduction in distress. For some people that distress does not reduce and
[00:33:26] continues to stay elevated. Our current diagnostic framework for prolonged grief disorder, it suggests that that period, if it, if that acute and elevated distress continues for a year after the loss, then there might be other kind of processes in place that might need formal intervention to reduce the distress. We, the, the field is, is in debate now. Should it be six months? Should it be a year?
[00:33:52] If someone comes, theoretically, someone can present with distress at, at, at 11 months and theoretically not receive intervention when they, because they don't quite meet the criteria for the year after. How many, how often does this occur? We, it's, it's not clear from the epidemiology, but the idea is that in grief generally, the acute distress, the acute reaction after the immediate loss should, should subside over time. Yes. Never go away, but it does subside.
[00:34:21] So prolonged grief disorder is an actual thing. I mean, it's an actual condition. And so I think it's fascinating. And I do, I want to go back to something that we were talking about earlier too, which is that all of this is so individual, right? It is so, we all are so specific as to how we process grief. And here's my other question for you. Does how we process grief change over time on the individual level? In reaction to one loss or reaction to multiple losses?
[00:34:49] Like I said, I lost another when I was in eighth grade, it like, yeah, not wrenching. And then I lose Ira when I'm in my late forties and it was even worse. They were both two very impactful experiences to me, but I would say that I have processed that differently. So as we, as we evolve as humans, as we age, do we learn, cognitively learn how to process it differently?
[00:35:12] Yeah. Yeah. It's a super interesting question and topic. So where, where, how do we, let me organize my, my, my comments on this? Cause it, you've touched a lot of, a lot of really interesting things about grief and recovery. So the, the, the one thing is there is some evidence to suggest that compounded experiencing many losses is associated with worse health. So the more people,
[00:35:41] it's just a volume. We think about stress diathesis, there's a volume of loss, a volume of trauma. People are going to have a harder time. Yeah. Yeah. So, so that, that's, that's, that's one piece, the volume, the number, it does, it does matter. The, the other piece that I'll introduce is a life stage at which we experience loss is also does profoundly shape our experience of it. So for children,
[00:36:06] for example, children are, children are undergoing massive developmental, cognitive developmental processes as they grow. Right. So the age at which a child experiences loss does, it is, is overlaying on their existing cognitive development world schema, we call it, or how they see the world or their cognitive infrastructure or their capacity to reason. So for two-year-olds to lose a parent is very different than for a 16 year old to lose a parent, just because of the cognitive architecture and the way that children see the world and reason and have logic.
[00:36:36] Right. So a loss at age is going to be very different than a loss when you are mid eight, middle age. It's, it's, we can also think about another way we think about this from the developmental perspective is on time or off time losses. So losses occur that are unexpected and off time. So for example, right, this is why I think friendships can be hard in mid age because it's, it's a bit early to start to lose people in middle age. So for example, children,
[00:37:04] parents losing children, very profound, very difficult to reconcile. Okay. So two questions. So first question is, and this is crazy, but I'll ask it. So is it harder on the child to lose the parent at two or the parent at 16 from what, from what your research has shown so far? Yeah, it is super interesting. Well, it, children, it's, it depends.
[00:37:29] That's not the best example, but, but, but it, it's a children are embedded. I always like, I always say children are embedded in an ecosystem of caregiving. Yeah. Right. So the parents and teachers and children and children are developing in this ecosystem, which profoundly affects their health and, and development and wellbeing. So it really depends on the role that that, on the, on that caregiver's role in a, in a child's life to a certain extent. So for example, this is an issue
[00:37:55] in childhood bereavement research is we don't have a really good way of actually measuring the type of relationship the child had with the parent. Yeah. We can give attachment inventories, we can do things, but to really qualify the profound kind of interaction that a child has with the parent is actually very, very difficult. But what we do find is for children who have the closest relationship with a parent and that parent dies, they have the elevated risk for PTSD and depression. So we're finding this in a study. So not surprised. So within that cohort, we can imagine people who've maybe
[00:38:25] never even met, never met a parent or never known the biological parent, but had other caregivers in their lives and had very meaningful connections too. And so, and so for, for children who experience, who are very close with a biological parent that dies, those children are at highest risk for dependency. So regardless of what stage of life it's in, whether they're two, 10 or 16, it's, it's just, if that child, if that parent, that, that, that, the research is mixed, but yeah. Yeah.
[00:38:51] But yeah, the, the role that the relationship with that parent has, has important profound shape and effect on the reaction to that loss. Yeah. It's the, just the whole thing to me is I just find it, I just find it so fascinating. The other thing I just, I just want to add as you, I wasn't, when you were describing the loss of your grandmother is something we, we, you touched on that I did, didn't want to highlight too, is, is that these profound relationships have, bring a sense of
[00:39:20] identity, a sense of meaning, a sense of connection. You said making gnocchi, like these carries cultural heritage, cultural traditions that are transmitted in these kin, in the interactions with loved ones. And when that person dies, much of that is also lost with them at times. Yeah. It's funny. Every time I was just in Italy for work and every time I go for pasta and eat gnocchi, I think of my grandmother. Like it's, it's, it's a very, very happy association, but I have vivid,
[00:39:47] very, very vivid slash fond memories of doing that with her. So, so the, the prolonged grief thing that we were talking about before, is that, is that associated with one specific type, is it primarily associated with one specific type of event, like death, for example, or is that something that, that's systemic across the grief categories of grief, shall we say? Yeah, it's, it's a good question. There is conversation around what does the death of,
[00:40:16] have to be of a loved one, of a person? Can it be another type of loss? A similar parallel conversation occurs in trauma research is what type of event qualifies as what we write criterion A or the, the trauma, right? So the current diagnostic conditions have evolved. And so with prolonged grief disorder, the current criterion for a index loss is the death of a person or a loved one.
[00:40:42] We do know people, of course, have reactions and profound reactions to deaths, other type of deaths and losses, including pets or places or things like this is an emerging area of research. But in terms of the current diagnostic conditions, it is anchored on the death of a loved one, a person. Does, does the grief response, whether it's death or something else, does that vary by gender? Are men more affected or are women more affected? Or is it all just down at the individual level in terms of
[00:41:09] the responses? Yeah, the findings are a bit mixed on that, but it looks like it's not necessarily patterned as profoundly by gender as other conditions. Like for example, depression or anxiety. We know from epidemiology that women are more often have a carry a higher prevalence of depression. The prevalence for prolonged grief disorder between men and women isn't, at least from the bulk of the research. Some studies suggest there is a difference, but the bulk of the research
[00:41:34] suggests they're fairly similar. Yeah, the whole thing is just so fascinating. And I did want to go back to something we were talking about earlier, which is this idea of social health and loneliness. Loneliness, I'll say this, I think often is an output of grief, right? We go through as we lose, we lose a loved one, for example, and we're lonely. Is there data or is there research, I'm sure
[00:42:01] there's some of it, besides that, other triggers for loneliness or are men in, again, back to the gender variability, is loneliness more prevalent among women or men? And is it, in your work, are you seeing that it is growing in epidemic proportions? The WHO study said loneliness is the equivalent, I think it was, loneliness is the equivalent of smoking 15 cigarettes a day in terms of the effect on
[00:42:25] the body. Why is it, why is it, why is the effect so profound from what you're seeing in your work? Mm-hmm. Again, that's Julia Hansel-Low's work that has generated some of the wider appreciation of the profound health effects of a cost of loneliness. Men generally tend to have fewer social relationships than women. Okay. And so, there is some sense that men do generally tend to endorse more loneliness.
[00:42:54] Um, than women. Women have a broader social network, generally, than women. Again, this defines, this is where things get, um, so interesting in grief and bereavement research because the, the way that we, so the social nature of the way that pair bonds are created and supported and marital bonds are formed in our society. And then the, so for example, there was a recent study from Japan
[00:43:21] that showed that after spousal loss, women did not show adverse health effects, but men did. So, after their spouse died, men experienced greater physical illnesses, worse mental health, whereas women did not. Interesting. Interesting. I haven't, I haven't necessarily seen such a, like a clear picture emerge. Generally, it's a bit more mixed. It depends. For example, there's another study that
[00:43:45] showed back to cardiovascular disease. Women who had cardiovascular condition prior to the death of their husband or their spouse had reduced risk for cardiovascular disease after the death. But that only, that only applied to women who had a preexisting condition. Right. So, men generally, the other interesting thing we don't talk as much about what I see this in
[00:44:12] my studies is remarriage is very, is protective for health. We can see if we compare remarried widowers, they are less likely to experience adverse health conditions across the lifespan. So, is it better to, if you experience a death of a spouse, is it better to get remarried or is it? Everyone wants to go. Yeah, as a one-to-one, yeah, everyone, yeah, just apply that finding to a
[00:44:35] recommendation. I don't know. On a population level, it does suggest remarriage, but we can think about why that might be the case, right? We think about health behaviors. We think about the ways that we pragmatically support each other. We think about the protective effects of having a partner. Right. Yeah. That's our next conversation. But we also know that, depending back to toxic relationships, for example, marriages where,
[00:45:03] or relationships that are characterized by interpersonal violence and domestic violence, these types of relationships do not support health and well-being for the victim, obviously. No. No. No. No. No. Yes. And I know many women or men, or I know many people who at one point in time felt that their relationship was toxic, and either they get through it or they don't. And again, that's a whole
[00:45:29] other conversation. But I just think that there's... And the other thing is, too, just the concept of grief, grief, right? I think even that needs more discussion and more clarity, because what I consider grief could be very different from what you consider grief. And I think that is also something that varies at the individual level and varies by gender. Am I right on that, too? Yeah. We have various kind of ways of defining grief in research, varying from an emotional sort of a mood
[00:45:58] or a persistent mood state. So that is an area that there's much more work to be done. Yeah. But just to say broadly, one of the things that interests me about the definition of grief and how we talk about it is we're communicating a certain societal approval of certain experiences versus others. So there's a term disenfranchised grief, which refers to the losses that society
[00:46:23] doesn't necessarily acknowledge or approve of. So one example is suicide losses, when people lose loved ones to overdose or to drug overdose. These sort of losses are not societally sanctioned or acknowledged. And so this has given rise to this term. And these losses can be more to process in the context of stigma, which can be very different. Yeah. We had someone on the show in season one who lost five family members to suicide.
[00:46:52] Mother, aunt, niece. It was a lot. And he just talked about, like, it's like not survivor syndrome. That's not the right word, but kind of is, right? It was just like, it was, how do you process all that? And two of them were back to back. And just, and also living in fear. The other part of it, which is interesting in that conversation, was the fear of, am I ever going to be that person? If this is in my family, depression, suicide, whatever, suicidal tendencies, am I ever going
[00:47:19] to be at that point? And that was something too, which was fascinating. There's just, there's so much there. Yeah. Yeah. Something I think a lot about, and we get, you've touched on this as well, is how we in community and conversation acknowledge loss and support a discussion and a broader re-envisioning or
[00:47:46] resurrection of how we honor and acknowledge and live with losses in our contemporary or in our current day-to-day life. So loss goes often acknowledged, unacknowledged, and it's somehow, there is a societal or community responsibility to acknowledge, a collective responsibility to acknowledge those losses because the burden isn't on the griever, right? To generate support.
[00:48:13] Right. It's on the community and their collective society to provide, provide some infrastructure for, to facilitate that conversation, which is what I think you're doing here with your podcast. Yeah, we're trying and I think, and I appreciate that. The goal really was and is to create a place where people are comfortable talking about what they've gone through and to be okay sharing
[00:48:40] how they've gone through it. So my, my, my last question for you is this. So if someone's listening to the show who just experienced a traumatic event and has grief and feels alone, based upon your research on the work that you've done, what are some tips that you can give them for, for navigating it? Because I think it's so often, it's such a solo journey. Mm-hmm. Yeah. And, and people feel like it's difficult to find resources because it is difficult
[00:49:07] to find resources. There is a, we call it a bereavement care gap. So there are a few things I would, I would, I would suggest. One is to find as, as, as, as defined by the individual, helpful community. Okay. And there are some informational. So Evermore is led by Joyelle Lutheran, who is leading a grassroots or a grassroots effort to, to engage American society
[00:49:36] in better agreement, bereavement support. Her website has a number of resources that can be filtered locally. So people go to their website. There is a search tool for bereavement and grief support resources in, in, in the local community. So for me, example, in Cambridge, I could go to the website and I could filter bereavement support by, by Cambridge and I could identify local communities or providers who are, who are near in my area where I could go. There are also online, online groups.
[00:50:06] I think the important thing about grief and bereavement also to remember is that unlike some other psychiatric conditions, there are range that it, that it isn't necessarily that people need therapy. People might need professional intervention if there's a consistent and persistent, elevated distress, but sometimes community support can be another way, finding a way to give back. Yeah. So purpose, finding meaning, we finding community, finding service. We know that these
[00:50:34] are also things that support a trajectory of wellness and protecting its disease over the life course. So an important thing I think for people to keep in mind is that there's, there really is no one recommendation for if people felt the onset, it's not like the medical model. If you feel, if you feel tachycardic, you should probably go see to the emergency room, right? Yeah, exactly. That's why everyone should do that. But in grief and bereavement, it's a bit different because people are different places. People have different needs. People come from different backgrounds. I think another thing we don't talk a lot about is engagement in community and religious
[00:51:04] communities. Some people have profound connections to religious communities and those can be very supportive and very helpful, but not for everyone. Right. Culture, cultural traditions, it can be very helpful and supportive. But I think, and also another helpful model that I think people find intuitively supportive is a dual process model. So the dual process model of coping and grief suggests that people vacillate between
[00:51:29] restoration-oriented activities and, and, and grieving activities. Okay. People go between, sometimes people are more outward focused on restoration and sometimes people are withdrawn and inward and both are necessary through the process. So it isn't that we should, everyone should be seeking engagement and support and maybe people need to withdraw and be alone. Yeah, they're, they're alone time. And I think as we've talked about so much, all of this is so
[00:51:55] individual. What's good for me may not be good for you and, or some of what you're doing may be good for me and I don't realize it. And I know one of the things that Karis and I talked about when we were talking about trauma was just the importance of, of sharing what you're comfortable sharing, right? Because the more you talk about it, it easier becomes. And, but, but again, one should talk about things that one is comfortable talking about. And I, and I know, I know for me, that's what we were talking about earlier. There are things that I share publicly about what I've been
[00:52:25] through and things that I don't, and I don't ever need to share everything because it's not anybody's business. I think whether it's trauma or grief, loss, whatever we're talking about, I think people need to understand that it's your story to share how much you elect or whatever. But I think it's interesting, this duality between the me time and the restorative stuff that I, that I think is so incredibly important. And I, I think also your point, seeking communities where you can
[00:52:52] find people that have shared common experiences. And, and, and, you know, what I've realized in my whole thing is everybody always has advice, right? There's so much advice in the world. And what I've also learned is sometimes it's okay to say, you know what? I appreciate that, but I'm going to my own way. And then there's other times where, yes. And there's other, yeah, let me be by myself. And then there's other times where I was talking to a friend about something
[00:53:20] the other day that happened. And the response was like, Catherine, don't focus on that mentally move on. And my other friend was right, but I got so stuck in, in, in what had happened. And yeah, no, I just, I just love, I love this conversation and we're going to have to have another one where we talk more about this because I think it's so incredibly important. I think I have to do a carousel on together to do our conversation. That'd be fun. Well, I like that we're ending on this acknowledgement of safety because safety is,
[00:53:45] especially in trauma, safety has to be there first. Safety is so important for survivor and also for people around supporting that person and sense of psychological safety, a sense of is, is, is so foundational. It's the first necessary foundation for supporting after trauma. And the same thing applies to grief to a certain extent. Yeah. That's great. It's so incredibly important.
[00:54:12] And people think we can listen, people have an internal meter. It was just feel good or not. And if it doesn't, then that's important information. That's exactly. That's a great note to end on. Christy, thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Love this conversation. Thank you. Oh my gosh. Such a good conversation. We could, and I am serious. We're going to have you back on and have Keras back on too, because I just think there's so much that we could talk about. And I think there's so much important information for people to listen to. So thank you for being here.
[00:54:41] Thrilled to be part of the conversation. Thank you. And thanks to all of you for listening to another episode of the Gut Punch Podcast. We'll catch you here next week. Bye-bye, everybody. That's it for today's episode of Gut Punch. I hope you found inspiration, because no matter how hard life hits, there's always a way forward. Make sure to follow or subscribe to Gut Punch on your favorite podcast platform. If you know someone who could use a
[00:55:07] little inspiration, share this episode with them. Thanks for listening. And until next time, stay strong. See you in the next episode.


